His season has been compared to that of the 2010 Heisman winner Cam Newton, who set an SEC record with 4,327 yards – a mark Manziel broke in two fewer games.
Manziel’s overall total offensive numbers (383.3 yards per game) dwarf Hundley (290.5), Mariota (266.8) and even Newton (308.1). His 43 rushing and passing TD are eight more than Hundley, nine more than Mariota and his average of 3.58 TD per game is right there with Newton (3.57 per game – 50 TD in 14 games).
But the numbers tell a different story when examining them closely.
Manziel faced three teams which are currently ranked. In those games, Manziel accounted for 293.7 total yards per game and 3 TD, nearly 90 fewer yards per game and well below his average of 3.58 TD per game. Compare that to Hundley, who accounted for 320.8 total yards per game and eight TD in four games versus ranked opponents.
Mariota played just two games against ranked teams and had 3 TD. He also gained only 6.3 fewer yards per game. In 2010, Newton faced, and beat, an amazing seven ranked teams, averaging 309.0 total yards per game and accounting for 25 TD.
Manziel Outperformed in Close Games
This season Manziel gained 1,402 of his total yards (30.5 pct) and 15 of his total TD (34.9 pct) when the Aggies led by at least 21 points. Those percentages are much higher than any of the other three QB.On the other hand, Manziel had the lowest percentage of output when the game was truly in doubt (when his team was tied or the margin was within seven points). Just 44.4 percent of Manziel’s total yards and 37.2 percent of his TD (16) came in this situation. This is where the comparisons to Newton fall well short.
In 2010, 65.6 percent of Newton’s total yards and 31 of his 50 TD (62.0 pct) came when Auburn was tied or in a game that was within seven points. Almost as impressive is how well Hundley performed this season under those situations.
Does this mean Manziel should not, or will not, win the Heisman? Of course not. But in this era of scrutinized performance, some may have decided to cast their historic Heisman vote for LB Manti Te'o of No. 1 Notre Dame, as opposed to a freshman who took the season by storm in early November.